About Puzzle's Insurance Agency, LLC

We are a new agency that can write for anyone in the state of Michigan. We may be new as an agency but our agents have a combined 30 years of experience in Insurance. We can write any insurance that you may need, auto, home, health, recreational, life, business(any kind). Please give us a call. We are experienced, knowledgeable, and friendly. We will help you find the right insurance at an affordable price. We are excited to hear from you!


Cari has been in insurance for 7 years. She worked with Farmers, Foremost, and Bristol West before moving to Puzzles Insurance. Cari enjoys playing with her kids, being at the toy store her and her husband own, and being outdoors. You may see Cari outside in the downtown Cadillac area most spring, summer, and fall days. She loves to be at the park, the fountain, and ride her bike around the lake. Cari also loves listening to music. She loves helping customers get the right insurance coverage and making sure they are fully protected. 

Peggy has been in insurance since 1999. She is a great resource of information. She worked for a few different agencies before coming to Puzzles Insurance. In her spare time you will find her quilting or reading. She loves to go to quilting conferences a few times a year, She has 3 adult children and 7 grand children. She loves to be around her grand kids. Peggy is a great asset to our new agency. 


Contact Information

Puzzle's Insurance Agency, LLC
856 N Mitchell St. 
Cadillac, MI 49601

Phone: 231-775-7778
Fax: 231-775-7785